
MUSE vs. RADIOHEAD: the big debate.
For many years, rock fans from all over the world have been arguing as to who are better: Muse or Radiohead? I have been both a Muse and Radiohead fan since I was very little. From the age of 8 or 9, infact. I recall inviting my friend Jimmy to come round, and we danced around my parents’ room to the song “Fillip” by Muse off their debut, Showbiz. But I also remember my parents playing OK Computer and me really, really liking it. I used to scribble all over my books at Primary school “Muse”. I did prefer them. But only when I properly listened to Radiohead, did I discover their sheer, undeniable genius.
So, let’s compare.
Albums: Radiohead brought out their first album “Pablo Honey” in 1993. Muse brought their first album “Showbiz” out in 1999. A 6 year gap between the debut albums. Radiohead could be a definite influence for Muse. In the NME, Radiohead have an average of 8.14 for their 7 album reviews, whereas Muse received an average of 7.8 for their 5 album reviews. 1 point to Radiohead.

Live: Evidently, shown by the pictures above, Muse are much more developed and interesting stage-wise. Their gigs are a thousand times more energetic than Radiohead’s are. No doubt of course; Radiohead are amazing live. Thom’s signature “convulsions” whilst performing make their gigs unique. Radiohead are extremely passionate when it comes to their music, but at times, when playing their “hits”, Thom doesn’t seem to care or to want to perform them. Compared to Muse, they put every inch of effort into their performances, and they really prove to their fans how much they care. 1 point to Muse.
Awards & Achievements: Altogether, Muse have recieved 25 awards, including Brits and EMAs. Radiohead have only won 10 awards. But in those 10 awards, 3 of them are Grammys, which Muse have failed to receive. Muse have had 3 number ones for their albums. Radiohead have had 5 albums as number ones. 1 point to Radiohead. 1 point to Muse.
I surveyed 50 friends about who they prefer; Muse or Radiohead?
Muse: 19 votes.
Radiohead: 31 votes.
It is evident who teens prefer out of the two.
Muse are a lot more mainstream than Radiohead are. If you mentioned Muse to a 16 year old who listens to pop, they would have heard of them. However, if you mentioned Radiohead to the same person, they probably wouldn’t have heard of them. You could argue that this makes Muse better than Radiohead. But fame does not justify which band is better. Muse are explorative with their approach to music. As are Radiohead, they are known for their electro style experimentations such as the song “Idioteque”. Muse explore classical music, and in the song “Undisclosed Desires”, it sounds a lot more pop-py and mainstream compared to their other music, but ironically they use a slap-bass technique which wouldn’t really be considered mainstream… sometimes it phases me as to how they can even be compared or put up against each other in an ongoing debate.
Who is the winner? I am a massive Radiohead fan. And I’m trying my best not to make this post biased. But in my honest opinion, I would vote Radiohead as the better band. I have a lot more respect for them as a band, they aren’t pretentious or “up their own arses”, and some may argue that is what Muse are. Muse’s theatricality may be mistaken for arrogance and self-indulgence, partially true, but they’re famous so they may aswell do what they can get away with. Radiohead are a lot more developed musically, and they create such beautiful songs.
So, the winner is: Radiohead.
If anyone objects to this statement, speak now or forever hold your peace.
Jessie Hutchings.